Toxic waste in Japan The burning issue
|
A penchant for wrapping everything in
plastic and then burning the rubbish
indiscriminately has turned Japan into
the dioxin centre of the world. Dioxins,
a highly toxic group of chemicals that
are known to cause birth defects, skin
disease and cancer, are produced when
polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and other
plastic waste is burned at temperatures
below 700 degrees celsius. So toxic is
dioxin that a dose no bigger than a
single grain of salt can kill a man.
A recant study by Nicholas Smith, from the Tokyo office of Jardine Fleming, a stockbroking firm, found that more than 100 of the 1,500 or so incinerators in Japan failed to meet the country's (already lax) dioxin emissions criteria. Japanese law allows 80 billionths of a gram of dioxin per cubic metre of air -- 800 times greater than typical standards in Western Europe and North America. Only eight incinerators in Japan actually meet the international norm. And one, in Hyogo, continues to spew out dioxin at 10,000 times the concentration allowed elsewhere. All that poison floating around in the air may pass unnoticed. But when it falls to earth and contaminates the soil and groundwater, it becomes harder to ignore. A wake-up call for Japanese industry -- on the scale of the Love Canal incident in America in 1980 -- came in April when the soil surrounding an incinerator in Nosecho, a residential suburb north of Osaka, was found to contain a staggering 8,500 picograms of dioxin per gram of soil. This has given Nosecho the unpleasant distinction of having the highest recorded dioxin concentration in the world. The outcry over the toxic waste that contaminated the soil at Love Canal in New York state prodded the American Congress into establishing a trust fund (the "Superfund") -- financed by a levy on the oil and chemical industries -- to clean up such sites. In the same way, Nosecho has focused public anger on industrial polluters in Japan. Rather than being hauled over the coals, sensible firms have started to publish ugly details about the frightening condition of some of their sites. |
First to come clean was Toshiba. In early
June, the electrical group reported
illegally high levels of a carcinogen,
trichlorethylene -- an industrial cleaning
agent that is believed to cause kidney
and liver damage as well as cancer -- in
the groundwater beneath four of its
domestic factories. The company carried
out on-site inspections of all its 25 plants
in Japan after detecting trichlorethylene
levels at 15,600 times the permitted level
at a factory in Nagoya last October.
Having found similar levels of the toxic
waste outside the plant, the local
government is checking the health of
residents in the neighbourhood.
Next a consumer-electronics giant, Matsushita, reported harmful carcinogen levels in the groundwater beneath four of its factories in the Osaka area. The level of the cancer agent tetrachlorethylene -- used for cleaning semiconductors -- at one of the plants was 9,400 times the permissible limit. At another plant, in Hokkaido, the groundwater contamination was 5,200 times the maximum. The company suspects that the groundwater beneath 80 of its 112 plants in Japan may be contaminated with harmful compounds. Such findings have come to light more than a year after Japan's amended Water Pollution Prevention Act came into effect. But the recent rush to reveal all has been prompted as much by the "Nosecho effect" as by the retroactive nature of the legislation, which forces the original polluter to clean up affected site. Other forces are at work, too. Japanese manufacturers have been adopting the international ISO 14,000 standard of environmental good housekeeping faster than those of any other country. By February, some 730 industrial sites in Japan had become fully compliant, compared with 525 in Britain and a mere 110 in America. Half of the Japanese plants that have complied with the new ISO standard are in the electronics sector. Being top exporters, Japanese electronics firms have been understandably nervous about having their goods barred from countries that are signatories to the ISO 14,000 |
agreement. To be awarded the ISO seal
of approval means making fundamental
changing in the way a plant is managed,
with strict planning, implementing,
checking and reporting systems put in
place. It is these, as much as anything,
that are encouraging Japanese forms to
clean up their act.
All of which is creating a handy new line
of business for Japan's environmental-
protection industry. Soil remediation in
particular is seen as having huge
potential. Kurita Water Industries, one
of Japan's leading environmental-
engineering firms, started building its
soil remediation skills over a decade ago.
It has carried out more than 400 surveys
and soil purification schemes to date. As
for Japan's filthy incinerators, the
remedial business could be even more
promising. Jardine Fleming's Mr Smith
reckons that rebuilding all the faulty
incinerators in Japan could cost a
whopping \9.2 trillion ($66 billion).
Many suspect that the opportunities
currently being exploited by the clean-up
industry in Japan are merely the tip of an
iceberg. Now that two of the country's
most respected industrial names,
Toshiba and Matsushita have voluntarily
surveyed their sites for toxic problems --
and gone public with their findings --
many more Japanese companies are
expected to follow suit. The pressure for
them to do so is increasing as they shut
old smokestack factories and redevelop
the land for other uses.
But the remedial work is not just
required at big manufacturers. The
Environment Agency of Japan points to
the plethora of small plating shops as the
country's worst offender in terms of
toxic waste, followed (surprisingly) by
dry-cleaners, hairdressers and public
bath-houses. Big industries such as
chemicals and electronics follow close
behind. So far, only a fraction of the
small backstreet offenders have had their
land surveyed. There is still a lot of nasty
stuff out there in the Japanese soil. And
an awful lot of work will be needed to
clean it up.
|